The Center has long supported Jeanine Gramick, SSND and Bob Nugent, SDS for their work with the homosexual community. As were many of our constituents we were saddened by the twelve year investigation that resulted in the harsh judgment of their ministry with gay and lesbian Catholics and their families. It was decided at the joint Board and Staff meeting last fall to address our public response to the Religious Life and Ministry Commission on two important aspects of church life: subsidiary and pastoral concern. In November, an 8th Day Center board committee wrote the following statement was addressed to members of the Religious Life and Ministry Commission, comprised of representatives of the National Conference of Catholic Bishops, to administrators of the Conference of Major Superiors of Men, of the Leadership Conference of Women Religious and of the Conference of Major Superiors of Women Religious.In writing to you we are acknowledging two important aspects of church life: subsidiary and pastoral concern. We see an importance in having groups closer to the ministry scene review the activities of ministry. We see it as essential that judgments regarding Sister Jeannine Gramick's and Father Robert Nugent's ministry to the homosexual community move away from a doctrinal context toward one that is more pastoral in tone. The pastoral setting emphasizes the good of people, seeking the truth of the situation from a pastoral perspective.
How do we know that? From complaints that the Vatican Congregations and Commission received from certain parties in the U.S. Who are they? It seems that this comprises only a small group of bishops and private individuals, as indicated by Sr. Jeannine's statement following her reception of the notification.
Were we to look at this from another perspective, where the good in question is that of the homosexual community and their families to whom Sr. Gramick and Fr. Nugent were ministering, we may see another facet of this situation. If we could do this, would it not be an instance of mission-in-reverse, where we allow the "other" (the homosexual community in question) to be the missionary the missionary toward us? Our mission theology has struggled with allowing this in other areas, for example, in dealing with the problem of polygamy and induction into the church.
Every Christian is called to be chaste according to his/her condition in life. The insistence on the fullness of the moral teaching of the church about chastity should spring from a pastoral emphasis, more than a doctrinal one. The fullness of the moral teaching should honor the limitations, confines and restrictions that circumscribe a person's condition in life. The language question in describing the moral nature of homosexual orientation and acts (i.e., objectively disordered and intrinsically evil*) is insensitive to the homosexual community. Focusing on a sense of mission that is open to their condition in life might help us succeed in finding more viable language to use. This is what Sr. Gramick and Fr. Nugent have attempted If persons more in sympathy with the situation of those whom Sr. Gramick and Fr. Nugent address had more prominence in the procedures leading to the notification, the approach to the "harmful confusion problem", with its concern "lest evil accrue to innocent parties", would have found different expression. This would have had the advantage of correcting the imbalance in the composition of those adjudicating the problem.
In this context of a pastoral approach and sense of mission, the issue of assent and dissent may not have emerged so forcefully. To the extent we place the emphasis on the good of persons over doctrine, assent and dissent loom less large. Why should not the assent in question be to an effective way of securing the salvation of the homosexual person i.e., as an overriding pastoral concern for his or her good? This focus also bears on the status of Catholic doctrine regarding homosexual acts and homosexual orientation: questions as to whether they both enjoy the status of definitive teaching by the universal and ordinary magisterium of the church assume a lower silhouette in the context we are suggesting here, one of mission to these persons.
We register, then, disagreement with the approach and the judgment leveled against the ministry of these two religious. We recognize the many years that church leadership has taken in trying to reach a felicitous reconciliation with them about their writings and activities. This is praiseworthy. However, we feel that the substance of this effort has taken place in the wrong venue, the doctrinal one. These procedures did not start this way, but they have concluded within the jurisdiction of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith.
Board of Directors and Staff of the 8th Day Center for Justice.
|
Kevin Carroll, OP Nieves de la Rosa, CSA Durstyne Farnan, OP Lynn Fangman, PBVM Joan Fisher, PHJC Deborah Fumagali, SSSF Jenny Howard, SP Marcelline Koch, OP Raymond Kozuch, SCJ Sebastian MacDonald, CP Armand Mathew, OMI Regina McKillip, OP Thomas Moran, CMF Barbara Nelson, IBVM Peggy Nolan, BVM Carlotta Oberzut, RSM Robert F. Pawell, OFM Marilyn Ring, OSB Marlene Schemmel, CSJ Patricia Schlosser, OSF Janet Thill, OLVM Mark Weber, SVD Jim Zelinski, OFM Cap |
Robert Bossie, SCJ Dolores Brooks, OP Kathleen Desautels, SP Mary Kay Flanigan, OSF John Gonzalez Christy Lytle, CSA Mary Ellen McDonagh, BVM Dorothy Pagosa, SSJ-TOSF Mary Martin Colbert, SSND
8th Day Centerings is published quarterly for sponsoring subscribers as a tool for education and action in the search for peace and justice in the world. Editorial Board: Dolores Brooks, OP; Kathleen Desautels, SP; Mary Kay Flanigan, OSF; Mary Ellen McDonagh, BVM. cover art: Matthew Miles, SCJ |
NOTE:* "Given the failure of the repeated attempts of the church's legitimate authorities to resolve the problems presented by the writings and pastoral activities of the two authors, the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith is obliged to declare for the good of the Catholic faithful that the positions advanced by Sister Jeannine Gramick and Father Robert Nugent regarding the intrinsic evil of homosexual acts and the objective disorder of the homosexual inclination are doctrinally unacceptable because they do not faithfully convey the clear and constant teaching of the Catholic church in this area." Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Notification Regarding Sister Gramick and Father Nugent,' (ORIGINS, 29.9, 136).
According to UNITE, the garment workers' union, a sweatshop has long
hours, unlivable wages and no benefits no paid holidays, no vacations,
no insurance, no pension. Workers in sweatshops are subject to
arbitrary
discipline and poor working conditions including oppressive heat in the
summer and freezing cold in the winter. Usually they are lawless
operations,
evading not only wage and hour laws, but also paying no taxes and
operating
in the underground economy hidden from public view. Some workplaces, be
they modern factories, fields, nursing homes, or sparkling hotels, may
not appear offensive at first glance. Yet the paltry wages, lack of
health
care coverage, and health and safety hazards, conspire to create
sweatshops
which degrade workers. The extent to which work is "sweated" in these
shops
can be gaged by the living and health conditions of the workers.
Drive for excessive profits can also create sweatshop conditions. Some businesses have sought to increase profits by driving down wages or increasing hours in ways that have led to sweatshop conditions. Three recent United States Department of Labor (DOL) investigations demonstrate the potential dangers. In a Nursing Home Compliance Survey, 30 percent of nursing and other personal care facilities did not meet the Fair Labor Standards Act provisions. Eighty-three percent violated overtime regulations, almost 20 percent violated child labor provisions and 13 percent did not meet minimum wage requirements. In a survey of poultry plants, over 60 percent were violating various wage and hour laws. DOL officials report that over 60 percent of Chicagoland restaurants were also in violation of wage and hour laws. Clearly, one driving force for nursing homes, restaurants and poultry plants is the desire to maximize profits.
Traditionally, workers sought to gain a voice in addressing their workplace issues by forming a union. However, U.S. workers face the same kinds of opposition to unionization that were exposed by demonstrations at the WTO talks in Seattle. Consider these statistics from a Cornell University study by Kate Bronfrenbrenner:
• One in four employers fire workers who are active in union campaigns - in all it is estimated that at least 10,000 workers are fired each year for exercising the freedom to join a union.
• Ninety-one percent of employers, when faced with employees who want to join together in a union, force employees to attend closed-door meetings to hear anti-union propaganda; 80 percent require immediate supervisors to attend training sessions on how to attack unions; and 79 percent have supervisors deliver anti-union messages to workers they oversee.
• Eighty percent hire outside consultants to run anti-union campaigns, often based on mass psychology and distorting the law.
• Half of employers threaten to shut down if employees join together in a union.
People of faith and justice want to know that comfort, in the form of the goods and services that are used every day, does not come at the expense of a degraded workforce, either here or abroad. Workers should be compensated in a way that will enable them to live decently and workplaces should be safe and humane.
Here are three things one can do to assure worker rights:
1. Look for the union label. Although many consumers make it a point to "Buy American", many products made in the United States are produced under conditions that are oppressive to workers. In addition, many countries besides the United States are home to unionized factories where workers are treated well. Supporting AFL-CIO approved boycotts also helps workers.
2. Join or form a religion-labor committee. There are currently interfaith committees for worker justice in 48 communities throughout the country. The National Interfaith Committee for Worker Justice can help one get started.
3. Organize worker justice workshops and distribute information in your church bulletin aimed at helping low-wage workers understand their rights.
The National Interfaith Committee for Worker Justice educates, organizes and mobilizes the religious community on issues and campaigns that will improve wages, benefits and working conditions for workers. 1020 W. Bryn Mawr Avenue, Chicago, IL 60660 773.728.8400 / 773.728.8409fax www.NICWJ.org.
The primary goal of the WTO's meeting was to begin a new round of global economic talks, referred to as the "millennium round." However, the international solidarity displayed in the streets of Seattle thwarted that goal of business-as-usual for mutinational corporations, in other words, mounting profits at the expense of human rights and the environment. Participants in the "millennium round" were unable to develop an agenda and those from developing countries who subsequently rejected a new round of talks seemed emboldened partly by the protesters in the streets.
Developing countries have long complained that they have been sidelined in trade talks by the WTO's secretive "green room" process, in which the decisions are made by wealthy nations outside of formal negotiations.
The crushing debt of these countries is directly linked to the special interests of multinational corporations. The Jubilee 2000 campaign has heightened an awareness of this situation. The overall disparity between the rich and poor has reached a level that surpasses anything in history. An economic system that perceives human beings and the environment as commodities and barriers to trade is not biblical and does not allow for sustainable life on planet earth.
Njoki Njoroge Njehu, director of 50 Years is Enough, was one of the Jubilee 2000 leaders in Seattle. She wrote, "Monday, November 29th, the eve of the labor rally and police crackdown … the streets belonged to Jubilee 2000. A huge crowd, estimated at 30 thousand…surrounded the Exhibition Hall where the WTO delegates were invited. They formed a human chain to call for debt cancellation for impoverished nations."
The unprecedented unity of numerous groups that occurred in the
streets
of Seattle was and is a critical part of the anti-WTO movement. It
demonstrated
that when corporate interests dominate governments around the world,
people
can act to pursue human interests above profits. Long standing tensions
and deep-rooted policy differences between the grassroots groups did
not
interfere with the coalition's ability to work together. Interaction
often
went beyond mingling to a respectful mutual education. A global civil
society
took shape.
| Due to this massive outpouring of opposition in Seattle, Americans are now more aware that the WTO acts as as a government in and of itself with the power to supersede the decisions of any national government, even those elected by the people. The WTO promotes corporate freedom over the democratic process. |
`They formed a human chain to call for debt cancellation for impoverished nations.' |
| Effectively the reemergence of civil society, non-governmental and non-church based organizations, is giving renewed hope for a world of right relationships |
Thus, I was thrilled last November, when invited to return to Kenya to celebrate the 25th anniversary of the first foundation of the School Sisters of Notre Dame. How exciting to join other pioneers of our first mission and to remember beginning experiences! How exciting to greet the new millennium on the African continent! I could hardly wait to see friendly faces and familiar places I loved so much ! And see them I did ! My heart was full of deep joy !
But there was sadness, too. I began to realize that something had changed. During early years in Kisii in western Kenya life was simple, but secure. The family was the center of life and work and every family had some land on which to do subsistence farming. No one went hungry and orphans were not visible as the extended family always cared for them. To my surprise, on my return last December, I found many "street children" in Kisii Town. There were so many, that the food left from the 25th anniversary celebration was shared with fifty hungry children who gathered around the parish house of the Catholic mission. What was happening ? Where were the extended families? The answer was simple but stark: AIDS was decimating the population of the area around Lake Victoria, especially in the towns of Homa Bay and Kisii. I discovered I had lost friends such as Appolonia and Rosemary to the disease and I suspected the sons they left behind were also infected.
Kenya, like so many other sub-Saharan African countries, ravaged by civil wars, drought and poverty, is losing a generation to AIDS. Hundreds are dying daily, leaving children who may also be infected. There is no medical care available for most of these victims. Because there is no effective educational program and no funding, people are living in fear and despair. Why not? Because what goes on in most parts of Africa, especially sub-Saharan Africa, seems to be of little interest to the rest of the world. The United Nations has all the statistics but very little monetary aid. Most of the affected countries are so weighed down by the burden of debt, there is no money for the medical and social care needed by the victims of AIDS .
Looking more closely at the situation it becomes evident that not only is the extended family disappearing, so is the work force - teachers, skilled workers, field workers. And the age of life-expentancy is dropping. The economic implications are staggering! When I returned I was surprised to see a series of articles in the Chicago Tribune about the spread of life-threatening disease in Africa. Then I saw the cover story in Newsweek (Jan. 17, 2000) on the 10 million orphans in Africa. Finally someone was paying attention to what was going on! Will help finally come? Will governments pledge funds to fight the disease? to give the Africans some cause for hope in the new millennium?
Upon closer examination, it is clear that this inspection regime will not lead to the suspension of sanctions because it continues to be official US policy to maintain sanctions until Saddam Hussein is replaced by someone more amenable to US interests. Apparently, Iraq's Foreign Ministry Undersecretary Niza Hamdoon was correct when he called the resolution a "process that aims at confusing public opinion," or what some call a public relations ploy to ease growing pressure to end sanctions.
Significantly, even after a year of wrangling and debate within the Security council to reach agreement on establishing criteria for confirming Iraq's disarmament and ending sanctions, France, Russian and China - three of the five permanent council members - were among those who abstained from voting for the current resolution. This highlights the sharp divisions within the council and exposes the pretense that continuing sanctions is the "will of the international community."
In this light, we should reflect on the failure of the former inspection regime, known as UNSCOM (UN Special Commission). UNSCOM ended in December 1998 when chief weapons inspector Richard Butler pulled all inspectors out of Iraq because, he said, the Iraqi government prevented the inspectors from visiting three sites. The pullout seemed especially suspicious at that time because, unknown to the US public, the inspectors had been allowed to visit hundreds of sites in the previous months. Also, Butler knew that the pullout would provide justification for the US and Britain to begin bombing.
Upon his return to the US, Butler reported directly to US officials, despite his responsibility being first and foremost to the Security Council. The US and Britain soon began bombing, both civilian and military targets, which continues every few days even now. A short time later, it was admitted that the inspection teams did contain US spies, as Iraq long contended, which was a clear violation of the UN mandate.
In the present context, even if the US could be persuaded to forgo the ouster of Hussein before lifting sanctions, the likelihood of significant relief for the Iraqi people would not occur for more than a year. The reason is that the new inspection regime - now known as UNMOVIC (UN Monitoring, Verification and Inspection Commission), would not begin for about a year due to the difficulty of choosing members of the inspection teams not intent on further US spying efforts. Meanwhile, Iraqi children will continue to die at a rate of 5,000 a month.
Once inspections do begin, the criteria for assessing Iraq's cooperation are so ambiguous that it will be relatively easy for the US or Britain to use their veto power to prevent the suspension of sanctions indefinitely. Meanwhile, it should be noted that Scott Ritter and other inspectors have stated that Iraq is essentially disarmed of all chemical, biological and nuclear weapons.
It is no wonder that the Iraqi government has refused to cooperate with resolution 1284. Yet in so doing, Iraq gives the US an excuse to intensify bombing.
Thus, these "genocidal" sanction, as they were rightly called by former UN humanitarian coordinator Denis Halliday, will continue. According to the May/June 1999 issue of Foreign Affairs, excluding the Nazi Holocaust, "Sanctions [on Iraq] have contributed to more deaths than all weapons of mass destruction throughout history."
8th day Center in its vision statement envisions a world of right relationships in which all creation is seen as sacred and interconnected. Thus, the Center commends Governor George Ryan of Illinois for his courageous step in halting state executions in Illinois. Others are urged to contact the governors of their respective states to take a similar move.The death penalty victimizes each of us over and over by its intrinsic devaluation of human life and its denial and rejection of reconciliation and redemption. From a perspective that values all creation, staff member John Gonzalez reflects on the birth of his daughter.
I was hired by the Congregation of the Passion in June of
this past year to be their staff person here at the center. This being
my seventh month here with this organization I am still limited to my
contributions,
yet on the 8th of December, 1999 (the feast of the Immaculate
Conception)
Karen (my wife) and I were able to contribute an experience that was
both
significant and original to the center. Estelle Elizabeth Gonzalez was
born to us on that day. Estelle's birth brought, amongst other things,
a new perspective for my wife, myself and the center itself.
This is of course the perspective of a newborn human life, a
life from which one can see the very basic meaning of being
human.
It is not life that has been molded by the various different
experiences
from which she will develop her own sense of individuality and place in
this world (with the exception of the experience of familiarizing
herself
with her own body). At this point she is innocent insofar as she is
untouched
by the aspects of both good and evil that this world will have to
offer.
She is at that point where all of us have begun. Her perspective then
is
that of humanity stripped of all its baggage. Yet she is also aware and
from this point on, she is growing.
She is frail, as an individual she cannot survive. Her survival
comes with the assurance that she is part of a community, thus from the
moment of birth she is a social creature. Yet she does not simply
burden
the community she was born into, she to has something to offer us. She
offers us the gift of hope through life. She (as well as her
contemporaries)
are the future instruments through which our world will function. How
she
will
play that role depends upon us. Will we teach her to value money above
all other things. Perhaps she will learn to push the interest of her
country
above all other things. Maybe, just maybe, she will learn to value the
salvific purpose Christ had in mind for all humanity. Maybe she will
learn
to value life above capital or national interest. Maybe she will learn
to cherish the love of God and interpret that love for all humanity.
Either
way she is our hope, the task ahead of us is to reassess what that hope
is.
A Prayer for the Journey from Violence into WholenessSpirit of God,we long to mend the broken circle. We long to heal the fractures in the world around us and within our own souls. To learn from one another the ways of living fully alive, To transform those parts of ourselves and out world that block our making contact with our deepest reality and with the deepest, richest and most sacred dimensions of all other beings. Spirit if God,
Spirit of God,
Excerpted from Violence to Wholeness, a tan part program by Ken Butigan in cooperation with Patricia Bruno, OP Pace e Bene Franciscan Nonviolence Center. |
|
When I tried to help the poor, people said I was a saint. When I asked why they were poor, they called me a communist," said Dom Helder Camara former Archbishop of Brazil and Nobel Peace Prize nominee. |
When called a saint by some of her contemporaries, Dorothy Day responded, "don't dismiss me so easily." |
In these statements, Dorothy and Dom Helder acknowledge the efforts
of the dominant culture to squelch the prophetic call to live the
values
of the kin-dom of God, wherever it finds roots in the community.
Regrettably,
we ourselves participate in this four step process of taming the
prophets
and, in so doing, diminish our own prophetic call.
Somehow, the belief is that prophets must be perfect, more than
human,
unlike ourselves. Perhaps the greatest gift of prophets is to
acknowledge
that they are simply tools of the Spirit of God and must stay true to
their
concern for the community despite their own weaknesses.
The treatment of those who "crossed the line" in a funeral
procession
onto the US military base housing the School of the Americas offers a
current
example. The protesters were prosecuted under criminal law and
incarcerated.
Any attempt by the protesters to raise the moral issues in trial were
quickly
squelched by the protectors of the system, the judges and prosecutors.
Regrettably, because many of us have made our peace with the status
quo,
from which we benefit enormously, we tend to agree with this
interpretation:
"Well, the protesters have a point but they have gone too far by
breaking
the law."
Since this effort has proved ineffectual, the powers now are "forced" to call upon the sacred right of the community, for whom they are acting, to use violence to protect itself. Again, the Scriptures are instructive: "Can you not see that it is better for you to have one man die than to have the whole nation destroyed." (Jn 11:50) "We have our law ... and according to that law he must die...." (Jn 19:7)
Some, such as Rene Gerard and Gil Bailie, have identified this act
of
sacred violence with the scape goat ritual of the Jewish testament.
Thus,
the powers kill the bearer of good news, often with the cooperation of
the community.
At this moment, the community is the most vulnerable because it recognizes the significance of the prophets and wishes to uphold them in a special way. But the risk is that we relegate the prophets to household gods with little if any power to move the community. They are unique, holy, beyond anything to which we can aspire. And so, unwittingly, we participate in killing not only the prophets but also their message. At least that is the goal of those who promote the dominant culture.
In the long struggle to create the beloved community living in
harmony
with creation, we have come to know that life is stronger than death.
For
the spirit of a faithful life continues to find root in new
generations.
Consider the following:
| We've been threatened with Resurrection
because we've touched their lifeless bodies and their souls have penetrated our own now doubly strengthened. Because in this Marathon of hope, there are always replacements to carry on the strength until we reach that goal beyond death. Be with us in this vigil and you'll know then how wonderful it is to be threatened by Resurrection. To dream, awake, to watch, asleep to live, dying and to know yourself already - Risen! (from "Threatened By Resurrection," Julia Esquivel) |
| * Reminder
April 21 is 8th Day's 20th Annual Good Friday Walk for Justice in Chicago. Check your own cities for Walks or contact us for help to start your own! * Resources
A program entitled "Women, Life, Leadership" has been developed for small group use. This three unit, six-session process of skill building for the promotion of women's leadership and use of power in daily living includes units on self-esteem and leadership. Each unit includes a reflection and action component and is available in English and Spanish. Contact Intercommunity Center for Justice and Peace, 20 Washington Square North, New York, NY 10011. Phone:212-475-6677. Fax: 212-475-6969. Liturgy Training Publications has published three new videos
that explore
the rituals of Holy Thursday, Good friday, and the Easter Vigil.
Each is 30 minutes in Length and designed to be used with the liturgy
committee,
the
|
guide containing reflection and
discussion questions.
The price is $39.95 each or $99.95 for all three. Call 1-800-933-1800 to order WTO Seattle is the most recent video acquisition of 8th Day Center. The video includes a section in which viewers become one of the peaceful protesters on the streets and a commentary by Professor David Ramey of the University of Illinois on why things fell apart for the WTO. Remember all 8th Day videos are available for borrowing by members of constituent congregations for the cost of postage. * In Memoriam
* Prayer Requests
|
and educational packets, contact
Burma Forum
of Los Angeles, 2118 Wilshire Blvd. #383, Santa Monica, CA 90403.
Phone:
310-399-0703. e-mail: zquante@igc.org.
* SOA Update
SOA-trained Guatemalan Col. Byron Disrael Lima Estrada was arrested, along with his son, in January for the 1998 murder of Roman Catholic Bishop Juan Gerardi. * Payroll deduction gifts
One can increase choice in giving in one's own state through promoting the work of local federations made of organizations focusing on social change. |
"Fasting is an institution as old as humans. It is my conviction that a fast undertaken out of genuine love cannot have any negative result. It will only bring good in its wake."-- Mahatma Ghandi
A subscription to 8th Day Centerings
is available for $15 per year or $25 for two years.
To subscribe, please call 8th day 312-641-5151
|
8th Day Center for Justice As religious communities of women and men grounded in the hope of the Scriptures and our Christian faith tradition, we collaborate in the struggle to provide a critical alternative voice to systems that suppress the human community and environment; to work for the structural changes which will hasten the arrival of a more just and harmonious world. |
|
Claretians, East, USA
|
Adrian Dominicans
|
Institute of the Blessed Virgin Mary Franciscan Sisters of Perpetual Adoration Our Lady of Victory Missionary Sisters Sisters of St. Benedict, Ferdinand, Indiana Sisters of St. Benedict, Nauvoo, Illinois Sisters of the Presentation, Dubuque, Iowa Sisters of the Humility of Mary, Villa Maria, Pennsylvania |